Welcome to my Murder Your Employer book review, where I dive into the wickedly clever world of Rupert Holmes’ 2023 mystery novel, Murder Your Employer: The McMasters Guide to Homicide. If you’re a fan of dark humor, intricate plots, and a touch of the macabre, this book might just be your next obsession. Published on February 21, 2023, this New York Times bestseller has taken the literary world by storm, earning praise for its originality and devilish charm. In this detailed review, I’ll explore the plot, characters, themes, and narrative style, share my personal insights, and weigh the book’s strengths and weaknesses. Whether you’re a seasoned mystery reader or just curious, stick around to see why this book is worth your time.
Murder Your Employer Book Review: What Is Murder Your Employer About?
A Sinister Premise with a Twist
Murder Your Employer: The McMasters Guide to Homicide introduces readers to the McMasters Conservatory for the Applied Arts, a clandestine institution where students don’t learn to paint or sculpt—they learn to kill. Set in the 1950s, this secretive school trains its pupils in the art of “deletion,” a euphemism for murder, with a strict moral code: you can only kill someone who truly deserves it, like a tyrannical boss or a corrupt employer. The novel follows three students—Cliff Iverson, Gemma Lindley, and Doria Maye—as they navigate their deadly education under the watchful eye of the school’s dean, Harbinger Harrow.
The story kicks off with Cliff, a disgraced engineer who attempts to kill his abusive boss but botches the job, landing him on McMasters’ radar. Recruited to the conservatory, he joins Gemma, a chemist with a vendetta, and Doria, a glamorous actress with her own dark motives. Together, they hone their skills in courses like “Poisons and Antidotes” and “Improvised Weapons,” all while plotting their “thesis deletions”—the final murders that will secure their graduation. Narrated by Dean Harrow, the novel blends a satirical handbook style with a gripping mystery, keeping readers guessing about who will succeed and who will pay the ultimate price.
Why This Plot Stands Out
What makes this Murder Your Employer book review so exciting to write is the sheer audacity of Holmes’ premise. The idea of a murder academy is both absurd and brilliant, blending the structure of a coming-of-age story with the stakes of a thriller. The 1950s setting adds a layer of retro charm, evoking noir films and classic whodunits while maintaining a modern sensibility. Holmes doesn’t just throw in murder for shock value; he crafts a world where every kill is justified, forcing readers to question their own moral boundaries. It’s a plot that hooks you from page one and doesn’t let go.
Meet the Characters: A Cast of Killers
Cliff Iverson: The Relatable Everyman
Cliff is the heart of the story, a down-on-his-luck engineer whose life unravels after his boss, Gus Wentz, sabotages his career. His bumbling attempt at murder lands him at McMasters, where he transforms from a nervous wreck into a calculated killer. Cliff’s relatability lies in his flaws—he’s not a natural-born assassin, and his internal struggles make him a compelling protagonist. His journey is one of self-discovery, as he learns to balance vengeance with morality.
Gemma Lindley and Doria Maye: Complex and Compelling
Gemma, a brilliant chemist, brings a quiet intensity to the trio. Her reserved nature hides a deep-seated anger, and her backstory reveals a personal tragedy that fuels her desire for justice. Doria, on the other hand, is all charisma and cunning, using her acting skills to manipulate those around her. Their contrasting personalities—Cliff’s earnestness, Gemma’s intellect, and Doria’s flair—create a dynamic group dynamic that keeps the story lively. Each character feels distinct, with motivations that are both understandable and chilling.
Supporting Cast and the Enigmatic Dean
Dean Harbinger Harrow narrates the story with a mix of dry wit and scholarly detachment, making him an unreliable yet fascinating guide. The faculty at McMasters, from the eccentric poisons expert to the stoic weapons master, add color to the conservatory’s bizarre world. Even minor characters, like the villainous employers, are fleshed out enough to make their fates feel earned. Holmes excels at creating a cast that’s as entertaining as it is morally ambiguous.
Themes Explored in Murder Your Employer
Justice vs. Vengeance
At its core, Murder Your Employer grapples with the question of whether murder can ever be justified. The conservatory’s code insists that only the truly despicable can be targeted, but the line between justice and vengeance blurs as the students plan their deletions. Holmes invites readers to sympathize with the protagonists while questioning their actions, creating a moral tension that lingers long after the final page.
Power Dynamics and Workplace Revenge
The novel taps into a universal frustration: the powerlessness of employees under tyrannical bosses. Each student’s target is a caricature of corporate greed or cruelty, making their desire for revenge relatable. In this Murder Your Employer book review, I can’t help but note how Holmes uses humor to highlight real-world issues like workplace toxicity and exploitation, making the story both cathartic and thought-provoking.
Identity and Transformation
McMasters isn’t just about learning to kill—it’s about reinventing oneself. Cliff, Gemma, and Doria undergo profound personal growth, shedding their past selves to embrace their new roles. This theme of transformation resonates with anyone who’s ever wanted to start over, adding depth to the novel’s darker elements.
A Masterclass in Tone
Holmes’ Witty and Polished Prose
Rupert Holmes, an Edgar Award-winning novelist and playwright, brings his theatrical flair to Murder Your Employer. The prose is sharp, witty, and dripping with irony, perfectly suited to the novel’s dark comedy. Dean Harrow’s narration feels like a lecture from a slightly unhinged professor, complete with footnotes and asides that add to the handbook-like structure. Here’s a favorite quote that captures the tone:
“At McMasters, we do not merely teach you to kill; we teach you to kill well. Efficiency, elegance, and ethics are our trinity.”
This blend of humor and menace keeps the story engaging, even during slower moments.
A Satirical Spin on the Mystery Genre
Holmes plays with mystery conventions, subverting expectations with twists that are both surprising and satisfying. The novel’s structure, which alternates between the students’ training and their real-world missions, builds suspense while allowing for character development. The 1950s setting is evoked through period-specific dialogue and details, like rotary phones and fedoras, without feeling gimmicky. It’s a narrative style that’s both nostalgic and fresh, making this Murder Your Employer book review a joy to write.
Murder Your Employer Book Review: Key Strengths of the Novel
Originality and Creativity
The concept of a murder school is unlike anything I’ve read, and Holmes executes it with flair. The conservatory feels like a real place, with its own rules, traditions, and quirks. This originality sets Murder Your Employer apart in a crowded mystery genre, earning it a spot on bestseller lists like the New York Times and USA Today.
Engaging Characters and Humor
The characters are the novel’s heart, each bringing something unique to the table. Holmes’ humor, whether in Harrow’s snarky commentary or the students’ banter, keeps the story light despite its dark subject matter. Readers on Goodreads praise the “laugh-out-loud moments” and “clever dialogue,” with one reviewer calling it “a wickedly fun ride.”
Pacing and Plot Twists
At 416 pages, the novel maintains a brisk pace, balancing training scenes with high-stakes missions. The twists, especially in the final act, are well-earned and surprising, rewarding attentive readers. Amazon reviewers note the “unpredictable plot” and “satisfying conclusion,” with one saying, “I couldn’t put it down!”
Weaknesses to Consider
Slow Start for Some Readers
While I found the opening engaging, some Goodreads reviewers mention that the first 50 pages feel slow due to the heavy world-building. The conservatory’s rules and history take time to establish, which might test the patience of readers who prefer immediate action.
Moral Ambiguity May Not Suit All
The novel’s playful approach to murder won’t appeal to everyone. Some StoryGraph reviews flag content warnings for violence, suicide, and sexual harassment, noting that the lighthearted tone can feel jarring against the grim subject matter. If you’re sensitive to ethical gray areas, this might not be your cup of tea.
Limited Exploration of Side Characters
While the main trio shines, some supporting characters, like the faculty, feel underutilized. I would’ve loved more insight into their backstories, as their eccentricities hint at untapped potential. This is a minor gripe, but it’s worth noting for readers who crave deep ensemble casts.
Why This Book Resonates
Writing this Murder Your Employer book review has been a blast because the novel taps into something primal: the fantasy of getting even. Who hasn’t dreamed of outsmarting a terrible boss? Holmes takes that daydream and spins it into a story that’s equal parts thrilling and hilarious. I found myself rooting for Cliff, Gemma, and Doria, even as I questioned their choices. The 1950s setting adds a layer of escapism, while the themes of justice and transformation feel timeless.
One moment that stuck with me is Cliff’s realization that killing isn’t just about the act—it’s about reclaiming control over his life. It’s a powerful metaphor for anyone who’s felt trapped in a toxic situation. The novel’s humor kept me smiling, but its deeper questions about morality and power left me thinking long after I closed the book.
What Others Are Saying
The buzz around Murder Your Employer is undeniable. On Amazon, it boasts a 4.4-star rating from over 2,000 reviews, with readers praising its “unique concept” and “sharp writing.” One reviewer writes, “Holmes has crafted a masterpiece of dark comedy. It’s like Hogwarts for assassins!”
Goodreads users echo this enthusiasm, with the book earning a 3.9-star average from over 7,400 reviews. A top review calls it “a deliciously twisted thriller that’s perfect for fans of Knives Out.” However, some readers note the slow start, with one saying, “It took a while to get going, but the payoff was worth it.”
On Reddit, fans on r/IReadABookAndAdoredIt rave about the audiobook, narrated by Neil Patrick Harris and Simon Vance, which was a 2024 Audie Award finalist. One user gushes, “The narration brings the humor to life—definitely worth a listen!”
Why You Should Read Murder Your Employer
If you love mysteries with a twist, Murder Your Employer is a must-read. Its blend of dark comedy, clever plotting, and memorable characters makes it a standout in the genre. Whether you’re drawn to the idea of a murder school or just want a fresh take on the whodunit, this book delivers. The audiobook, available on Audible, is a fantastic option for those who prefer listening, with Harris and Vance’s narration adding extra flair.
Ready to dive into this diabolical thriller? Grab your copy from Amazon or your local bookstore and prepare for a wild ride. You won’t look at your boss the same way again! Purchase Murder Your Employer on Amazon.
Visual Elements to Enhance Your Experience
To bring the book to life, here are some visuals you might enjoy:
- Cover Image: The hardcover features a sleek black design with a blood-red diploma, hinting at the novel’s deadly academia theme.
- Key Quote: “To delete is not to destroy but to correct a cosmic error.” – Dean Harbinger Harrow. This sums up the conservatory’s warped philosophy.
- Mood Board: Picture fedoras, typewriters, and shadowy alleys to capture the 1950s noir vibe.
A Killer Read Worth Your Time
In this Murder Your Employer book review, I’ve tried to capture what makes Rupert Holmes’ novel so special: its bold premise, vibrant characters, and razor-sharp humor. Despite a slightly slow start and some moral ambiguity, the book’s strengths—its originality, pacing, and wit—far outweigh its flaws. It’s a thriller that entertains while challenging you to think, wrapped in a package that’s as stylish as it is sinister.
Whether you’re a mystery aficionado or just looking for something new, Murder Your Employer deserves a spot on your shelf. So, what are you waiting for? Enroll in McMasters Conservatory and discover why this book is a bestseller. Happy reading, and maybe keep an eye on your boss—just in case.
“Enjoyed this review? Discover more in our Fiction Reviews section.”
