There are books that entertain, and then there are books that hijack your brain, twist it into knots, and leave you questioning everything you thought you knew. Alice Feeney’s debut novel, Sometimes I Lie, firmly falls into the latter category. From the moment you pick it up, you’re plunged into a world where reality is a shifting concept, and the protagonist’s own mind is the most dangerous landscape of all. As a long-time enthusiast of psychological thrillers, I can confidently say that this book delivers on its promise of suspense, deception, and a truly unforgettable reading experience. If you’re looking for a deep dive into the human psyche, a narrative that constantly keeps you on your toes, and an answer to the burning question of “what just happened?”, then this Sometimes I Lie book review is for you.
Feeney masterfully constructs a narrative that is both disorienting and utterly compelling, ensuring that readers are hooked from the very first page. It’s the kind of book you devour in a single sitting, or at least try to, because putting it down feels like abandoning a vital puzzle mid-solve. But be warned: this isn’t a passive read. It demands your full attention, a willingness to suspend disbelief, and an open mind to the myriad possibilities of truth and illusion.
The Premise: Waking Up to a Nightmare
The story opens with one of the most chilling and effective hooks I’ve encountered in recent memory:
“There are three things you should know about me:
- I’m in a coma.
- My husband doesn’t love me anymore.
- Sometimes I lie.”
This immediate confession from our protagonist, Amber Reynolds, sets the stage perfectly for the unreliable narrative that is about to unfold. Amber is trapped in her own body, a prisoner of her mind. She can hear everything around her – the hushed conversations of her husband, Paul, the worried tones of her sister, Claire, and the medical staff discussing her prognosis – but she cannot move, speak, or even open her eyes. This unique vantage point, combined with her startling admission of dishonesty, makes for an incredibly tense and claustrophobic reading experience.
As Amber lies unresponsive in her hospital bed, her consciousness flits between three distinct timelines: the “Now,” where she desperately tries to piece together what led to her coma; the “Then,” detailing the events of the week leading up to her accident; and the “Before,” fragmented diary entries from her childhood twenty years prior. Each timeline offers tantalizing clues, but also serves to deepen the mystery, constantly challenging the reader’s perception of what is real and what is merely a fabrication of Amber’s fractured mind. This intricate structure is a testament to Feeney’s plotting prowess, ensuring that every revelation is met with a new layer of intrigue.
Deconstructing the Twisted Plot of Sometimes I Lie
To truly appreciate this novel, one must delve into its labyrinthine plot, which is less a straight line and more a series of dizzying switchbacks. The core mystery revolves around Amber’s accident: was it a tragic mishap, an attempted murder, or something far more sinister involving her own actions? Her suspicion immediately falls on her husband, Paul, a seemingly successful novelist whose affection seems to have waned. As Amber’s memories trickle back, we witness the unraveling of her marriage, her fraught relationships, and the professional turmoil that plagued her life before the coma.
The “Then” timeline paints a picture of a woman on the brink. Amber’s career as a radio presenter is under threat from a ruthless colleague, Madeline Frost. Her home life with Paul is strained, riddled with accusations of infidelity and a palpable sense of unease. Feeney masterfully creates a sense of escalating tension in this pre-coma period, hinting at the desperate measures Amber might have taken, or been subjected to, to rectify her crumbling world.
However, it’s the “Before” timeline – the childhood diary entries – that truly throws a wrench into the works. These entries, ostensibly from a young girl named Amber, recount a disturbing and traumatic past, detailing a dark secret involving her sister, Claire. The revelations in these sections are genuinely unsettling, providing a chilling backstory that gradually connects to Amber’s present predicament. The question of who is writing these diaries, and whether their contents are entirely truthful, becomes another layer of the puzzle, further cementing the book’s reputation as a masterclass in unreliable narration.
As the story progresses, the lines between Amber’s different realities blur, and the reader is constantly forced to re-evaluate every piece of information. Just when you think you have a handle on the truth, Feeney pulls the rug out from under you with another shocking twist. This relentless barrage of revelations can be exhilarating, but also, at times, a little disorienting, which is precisely the point. The novel is designed to make you feel as trapped and confused as Amber herself.
Characters: A Study in Imperfection and Deceit
One of the greatest strengths of Sometimes I Lie lies in its complex and deeply flawed characters.
- Amber Reynolds: She is, without a doubt, the beating heart (and unreliable brain) of the story. Her direct confession of lying immediately makes you question every word she says, yet you can’t help but be drawn into her struggle. As she recounts her memories, we see flashes of vulnerability, desperation, and perhaps, a darker, more manipulative side. She’s not a heroine to root for in the traditional sense, but her psychological journey is utterly captivating. Her existence in a coma, a sentient observer unable to communicate, creates a unique form of suspense, as you’re privy to her internal monologue and the external actions of those around her.
- Paul Reynolds: Amber’s seemingly estranged husband, Paul, is initially presented as a prime suspect. He’s a novelist, often retreating into his own world, and his relationship with Amber is clearly fractured. However, as the narrative progresses, Feeney complicates his portrayal, making you wonder about his true motivations and whether he is a victim, a villain, or simply another pawn in a much larger game of deception. His presence by Amber’s bedside, his whispered apologies, and his seemingly genuine concern add layers of ambiguity to his character.
- Claire: Amber’s sister (or is she?), Claire, is perhaps the most enigmatic and disturbing character. Her relationship with Amber is fraught with history, jealousy, and unspoken resentments. The childhood diary entries reveal a past that is deeply unsettling and suggests a truly toxic bond. Claire embodies the idea that appearances can be deceiving, and her role in Amber’s life is far more significant and sinister than initially meets the eye. She represents the long shadow of past trauma and how it can poison present relationships.
- Edward Clarke: Amber’s ex-boyfriend, who unexpectedly reappears as an orderly at the hospital, adds another layer of menace and unresolved conflict. His presence raises questions about his past with Amber and his potential involvement in her current state. He is a source of tangible threat within Amber’s helpless “Now” reality, adding to the palpable fear she experiences.
Even secondary characters like Madeline Frost, Amber’s rival at the radio station, contribute to the intricate web of deceit, showcasing the cutthroat world Amber inhabited before her coma. Each character is crafted to be multi-faceted, keeping the reader guessing about their true intentions and their role in the unfolding drama.
Themes Explored: Truth, Memory, and the Self
Sometimes I Lie is not just a thriller; it’s a profound exploration of several powerful themes:
- The Nature of Truth and Lies: This is, without a doubt, the central theme. The book constantly asks: What is truth? Can we ever truly know it, especially when our own perceptions are flawed? Amber’s opening statement, “Sometimes I lie,” forces the reader into a state of perpetual distrust, making them question every detail, every memory, and every character’s motivations. It delves into the idea that lies can be a form of self-preservation, a way to cope with unbearable realities, or a tool for manipulation.
- Memory and Perception: The fragmented nature of Amber’s memories is crucial. How much can we trust what we remember, especially when under extreme duress or trauma? The narrative demonstrates how memory can be a fluid, unreliable thing, susceptible to distortion, suppression, and even invention. It highlights the psychological impact of trauma on our ability to recall events accurately.
- Identity: Who is Amber, really? Is she the victim she perceives herself to be, or is she something far more dangerous? The multiple timelines and the revelations about her past force a constant re-evaluation of her identity. The book suggests that our identities are not fixed, but are shaped by our experiences, our relationships, and the stories we tell ourselves – and others. The idea that one can play different “roles” (Amber the friend, Amber the wife, Amber from work) resonates deeply with the human tendency to adapt our persona to different situations.
- Toxic Relationships: The dynamic between Amber and Claire, in particular, is a dark exploration of how love, obsession, and manipulation can intertwine to create destructive bonds. It delves into the long-lasting impact of childhood trauma and the ways in which unhealthy attachments can perpetuate cycles of pain and deceit.
- Betrayal: Every relationship in Sometimes I Lie seems to be touched by betrayal, whether it’s marital infidelity, professional backstabbing, or the ultimate betrayal of trust between siblings. The book showcases the devastating ripple effects of broken trust.
Feeney weaves these complex themes together seamlessly, ensuring that the novel is not just a thrilling ride but also a thought-provoking commentary on the human condition.
Language and Narrative Style: A Masterclass in Suspense
Alice Feeney’s writing style in Sometimes I Lie is precise, evocative, and perfectly suited to the psychological thriller genre. She employs a crisp, straightforward prose that, despite its clarity, manages to convey an underlying sense of unease and tension. It’s a testament to her skill that even in moments of seemingly mundane hospital observations, the reader feels the weight of Amber’s unspoken fears and unanswered questions.
The most distinctive aspect of the narrative is its multi-layered structure. The alternation between “Now,” “Then,” and “Before” timelines is executed with remarkable finesse. This technique not only keeps the plot moving at a rapid pace but also serves to build suspense incrementally. Each chapter reveals a tiny piece of the puzzle, forcing the reader to constantly re-evaluate their theories and piece together the fractured narrative. This is not a book you can skim; every detail, every sentence, feels significant.
The use of an unreliable narrator, hinted at from the very beginning, is the cornerstone of the novel’s brilliance. Amber’s internal monologue is fragmented, contradictory, and often self-serving, making the reader constantly question what is true and what is a convenient fabrication. This deliberate ambiguity is incredibly effective, creating a sense of delicious uncertainty that propels the story forward. As one reader aptly put it, “The author set it up perfectly, framing the narrative secrets just right so that I didn’t even fully work out the questions I should be asking, never mind the answers.”
Feeney also sprinkles in short, impactful sentences and observations that stick with you, such as this profound thought:
“People think that good and bad are opposites but they’re wrong, they’re just mirror images of one another in broken glass.”
This quote perfectly encapsulates the moral ambiguity that pervades the entire narrative, suggesting that no character is entirely good or evil, but rather a complex blend of both.
Strengths and Weaknesses: A Balanced Look
Every book has its merits and its minor imperfections. Here’s my honest take on the strengths and a few areas where Sometimes I Lie might be less universally appealing:
Strengths:
- Ingenious Plot & Twists: The sheer number and cleverness of the plot twists are phenomenal. Just when you think you’ve figured it out, Feeney throws another curveball. This book is a masterclass in misdirection and will genuinely shock even the most seasoned thriller readers.
- Unreliable Narrator Done Right: The immediate confession of lying sets a brilliant tone. It’s not a gimmick; it’s integral to the story’s fabric, making the reading experience actively engaging as you try to discern truth from fiction.
- Compelling Pacing: Despite the fragmented timeline, the story moves at a relentless pace. Each chapter ends with a hook, urging you to read just one more. I found myself tearing through pages, desperate to uncover the next revelation.
- Unique Premise: The concept of a protagonist trapped in a coma, fully aware but unable to communicate, is a fresh and terrifying take on suspense. It adds a layer of vulnerability and psychological terror that is truly effective.
- Psychological Depth: Beyond the twists, the book delves into complex psychological themes: trauma, identity, memory, and the dark side of sibling relationships. It offers more than just a surface-level mystery.
Weaknesses (or points of contention for some readers):
- Over-the-Top Twists (for some): While I personally enjoyed the abundance of twists, some readers might find them too numerous or outlandish towards the end, pushing the boundaries of believability. This can lead to a sense of “too much” for those who prefer a more grounded narrative.
- Convoluted Ending: The very last few pages can leave some readers feeling more confused than satisfied. While it aims for ambiguity and further questions, it might not provide the neat resolution some prefer. As one Goodreads reviewer commented, “I’m just really relieved that I’m not the only person struggling with this – not sure its a good thing if you have to spend half hour googling an explanation and not being able to find one!”
- Unlikable Characters: If you need a protagonist to fully root for, Amber Reynolds might be challenging. Her flaws and admissions of deceit mean she’s not always likable. However, for fans of morally ambiguous characters, this is a strength.
- Disturbing Content: Some elements, particularly regarding Edward Clarke, are quite dark and might be unsettling for sensitive readers.
Personal Analysis, Insights, and Reflections
Reading Sometimes I Lie felt less like reading a book and more like being invited into a carefully constructed psychological experiment. From the moment Amber declares her unreliability, my internal alarm bells went off, and I found myself reading with a heightened sense of vigilance, trying to spot the subtle clues and blatant misdirections. Feeney does an exceptional job of making you doubt not just Amber, but every single character’s intentions, creating an almost paranoid reading experience (in the best possible way!).
The interplay between the different timelines is where the novel truly shines. The contrast between Amber’s helpless state in the “Now” and the frantic, manipulative actions in the “Then” creates incredible tension. But it’s the “Before” diaries that truly haunt. They are raw, disturbing, and hint at a foundational trauma that explains so much of Amber’s complex psychology. It’s a brilliant way to drip-feed backstory without ever feeling like an information dump. The slow reveal of the true nature of Amber and Claire’s relationship, and the events of their childhood, is chilling and impactful.
What resonated most with me was the exploration of how deeply our past, especially childhood trauma, can shape our present reality and our very perception of truth. The book powerfully illustrates that sometimes, the lies we tell ourselves are the most dangerous ones, creating a reality that is both a shield and a prison. The ending, while undeniably divisive, left me pondering the events long after I finished the last page. It’s a testament to Feeney’s ability to craft a story that is not easily forgotten, even if it doesn’t tie everything into a neat bow. It encourages discussion and multiple interpretations, which, for a psychological thriller, is often a sign of success.
Short Reviews and Impressions from Readers
A quick scroll through Amazon and Goodreads reviews for Sometimes I Lie reveals a consistent theme: readers are often left astonished, bewildered, and deeply impressed by the book’s twists.
Many echoed sentiments like:
- “This book will mess with your head!”
- “So many twists around every corner, the reader gets whiplash.”
- “Deliciously, utterly, and amazingly confused.”
- “I literally had to stop reading at one point and rethink everything I thought I knew.”
- “A crazy, intriguing, twisty-turny psychological thriller that makes your heart pound and leaves you completely dumbfounded.”
The phrase “unputdownable” appears frequently, highlighting the novel’s gripping nature. Readers praise Feeney’s ability to keep them guessing until the very last pages, with many admitting they did not see the final reveals coming. The unique narrative structure and the unreliable narrator are consistently cited as key strengths.
However, as observed in my personal analysis, some reviews also reflect the occasional frustration with the sheer volume of twists, with comments like: “it became borderline comical, like how many horrific events can happen to one woman within a week time span?” or “the first two-thirds of the book was good; then it fell apart and became too convoluted.” Yet, even these critiques often preface their remarks with an acknowledgment of the book’s initial compelling nature, proving its undeniable impact. The general consensus points to a divisive but ultimately memorable reading experience.
Why You Should Dive into Sometimes I Lie
If this Sometimes I Lie book review has piqued your interest even slightly, then do yourself a favor and pick up a copy of Alice Feeney’s debut. This is not just another psychological thriller; it’s a masterclass in suspense, a fascinating study of memory and identity, and a testament to the power of an unreliable narrator.
Are you prepared to question everything? To doubt the protagonist, the secondary characters, and even your own interpretations? Sometimes I Lie demands your full attention, but it rewards you with a reading experience that is both exhilarating and unsettling. It’s a fantastic choice for book clubs, as it provides endless discussion points about perception, truth, and the nature of mental illness.
Don’t miss out on this captivating and utterly immersive read. It’s a chilling journey into the depths of a fractured mind, where the truth is elusive, and the lies are painstakingly crafted. Go ahead, buy Sometimes I Lie and prepare to be genuinely surprised. Just remember: sometimes, even a book review can lie… but not this one. I truly believe you’ll find it an unforgettable ride.
A Thriller That Lingers
In conclusion, Sometimes I Lie by Alice Feeney is a standout in the psychological thriller genre. Its audacious premise, intricate plotting, and profound exploration of deception, memory, and identity make it a truly remarkable debut. While its multitude of twists might divide some readers, its ability to keep you guessing, to make you question every assumption, is undeniable.
Feeney demonstrates a remarkable talent for crafting suspense and manipulating reader expectations, delivering a narrative that is as disorienting as it is compelling. This Sometimes I Lie book review ultimately recommends it to anyone seeking a deeply psychological and relentlessly twisting read that will stay with you long after the final page. It’s a powerful reminder that sometimes, the most terrifying secrets lie not in the dark corners of a house, but within the confines of our own minds.
“Enjoyed this review? Discover more in our Mystery Reviews section.”
